Should You Repair or Replace Your Roof?

Have you just found your roof shingles in your backyard? Or perhaps you just discovered multiple roof leaks in your living room. Whatever the problems you’re facing right now, you know you have to either repair or replace your roof.

But which method is better? When should you one over the other? Let’s find out in this article.

Reasons To Repair Your Roof

Here are a couple of reasons when you can consider to just repair your roofs:

1. The Damage Is Minor

If your damage is minor, you could just easily get away with some roof repair. Roofs get damaged all the time, and in most cases, the damages are just minor. This include issues like:

  • Minor holes
  • Shingles damage from tree branches
  • Minor leaks
  • Nail pops
  • Minor weather damage
  • Granule loss
  • Shrinkage

These issues can easily be detected after a thorough roof inspection. That’s why we recommend scheduling at least two inspections of your roofs per year.

2. You Have Just Installed A New Roof

If you have just installed a new roof and discovered that there’s a water leakage coming from your ceiling, then consider repair a roof would be a viable option in this case.

Moreover, a new roof will always has a warranty anyway, so you shouldn’t worry about the budget in this case.

3. You Need A Temporary Fix In A Short Time

A roof repair can provide a quick temporary fix to any kind of roofing difficulties, especially when you’re in a tight budget. But as you probably know, this solution isn’t viable in the long run, when it comes to fixing major underlying problems such as broken shingles, roof rot, or attic insulation leakage.

We always recommend any homeowners to choose to repair their roofs to prolong the trouble until they have enough money to go for a roof replacement, which is the ultimate solution to any roofing problems.

4. When You Start Seeing Some Warning Signs

Any roofing worries, if left untreated, can be out of control and the only solution left is to replace that roof. So if you see any of these warning signs, then you should start considering your roof immediately before it’s too late:

  • Moisture Marks: If you see moisture marks, brown stains or peeling paint along the upper reaches of any wall, those are indicators of leaks in the areas in question.
  • Chipped Shingles: If portions of your shingles are chipped or appear damaged to the naked eye, you should have them inspected by a roofing specialist.
  • Interior Leaks: A leak of any kind is the most urgent sign of roof trouble. If water is dripping through your ceiling in any part of your living quarters, call a roofing specialist immediately.

Benefits Of Getting Your Roof Repaired

  • More affordable than replacing your roof
  • Faster to be executed
  • Help maintain your old roof
  • Can sometimes be done by yourself

Downsides Of Getting Your Roof Repaired

  • Matching shingles color can be difficult
  • Can sometime lead to more long-term damages for underlying problems due to poor choice made

That’s all for when you should repair your roof. Let’s move on to when to go for a roof replacement

Reasons To Replace Your Roof

Here are a couple of reasons why you should consider replacing your entire roof system:

1. The Damage Is Out Of Control

As mentioned in the above point, roof repair can be considered when the roof damage is minor or you want a quick temporary fix. But when you face with large damage such as a major roof leak, then a roof replacement is the best option to choose.

As a rule of thumb, roof repairs can remedy damages that cover only 30 percent or less of your roof. Any amount of damage beyond that threshold will likely leave you with no other option but to purchase a new roof altogether.

Want to learn more? Check out roof tear off vs overlay

2. Your Roof Has Reached It’s Limit

An average lifespan of a roof is about 25 years old. If you have been using your roof over 30 years old and have been constantly facing various problems, then it’s better to opt to replace your shingles and the entire roofing system.

When opting for a roof replacement, make sure to consult with a roofing company regarding the roof insurance and warranty. The cost factor also comes into play here. The cost of a new roof varies based on its material. For instance, metal roofs are more expensive than asphalt shingles.

3. Your Roof Does Not Compliant With The Current Building Codes

In certain cases, you might find out that your roof does not compliant with the current building codes in your area and since you might already have two layer of shingles over the old roof layer, then the last resort for this is go for a roof replacement.

Making sure that your roof conforms with the latest and current building codes helps prevent any possible problem in the future if you decide to sell your property.

4. You Want An Entirely New Roof

Another reason why you might want to use this method is simply that you want an entirely new roof for your house. A new roof makes your house more appealing, fresh, and most importantly, increase your property value.

This method gives you an opportunity to install a new roof material which overall, can strengthen and bring more value to your house.

Benefits Of Replacing A Roof

  • Help eliminate long-term roofing problems and damages
  • Help increase property value
  • More flexible with roof choices (material, color, etc.)

Downsides Of Replacing A Roof

  • Can be very noisy
  • Required large preparations beforehand – such as to inform neighbors, remove pets, etc.
  • More expensive
  • Take a longer time to complete a job
  • Can’t be done by yourself

Sharing is caring!