Metal Roofs vs Asphalt Shingles: Pros & Cons

metal roofs vs shingle roofs

Metal roofs vs asphalt shingles, one of the most debated topic among homeowners as to which type of roofing material is the best and most suitable for them.

On one hand, you have best roofing material available in the market. On the other hand, you have the most common roof type used by many people.

In this article, we have highlighted out the main differences between these 2 roof materials to help you choose the right one for your building.

Without further, let’s dive right into the details.

Metal Roofs Pros and Cons


Low maintenance – Due to metal roofing’s higher durability, the maintenance is required is significantly low, compared to other roofing materials such as asphalt shingles

Higher strength & durability – Compared to shingles, metal has higher strength and durability. They are widely considered as the most durable roofing materials available, besides slate roofs. Metal roofs are fire, lightning and climate resistance. They can tolerate harsh weather and are almost leak-free.

Many colors to choose – Metal roofing has so many colors that you can choose from. The roof styles which intimidate other non-metal roof style is also available.

Long-lasting – Metal roofing have an average lifespan of 40 to 70 years. This roofing material has one of the longest lifespan compared to other material available.

Energy-efficient – Metals are much more energy efficiency. They have a cooling coil system, that release absorbed heat in higher temperatures and retain heat in cooler temperatures. This helps save you more electricity bills.

Eco-friendly – This material highly recyclable, meaning leftover pieces, tear-off panels, or damaged parts can be recycled for future use.

There are metal coils and sheets that are made up of previously recycled materials. If the underlayment, which is laid above the roof deck and underneath the metal panels to protect against moisture, ice, vapors, and high temperature, is 100% polypropylene, it can be recycled.

Lightweight – Metal roofs are much lighter than asphalt shingles. In fact, they are one of the lightest type of roof you can purchase. The material weighs between 0.90 – 1.00 lbs. per square foot.

Higher ROI value – According to the stats, a metal roof has a whopping 68.4% ROI, which is one of the highest. This makes it to have a higher resale value.


Difficult to install – Metal roofing are generally more difficult to install and maintain, and often require experts with specialized knowledge to handle the work. They are not easy for DIY roof installation and repair.

Expensive – Average price for a metal roof material is $11.00 to $12.00 per square foot and the average labor cost for a roof installation is $5.50 to $12 per square foot. The total cost is roughly 3 times higher than shingle roofs.

Less variety – Metal roof generally has less variety to choose from, compared to asphalt shingle.

Asphalt Shingles Pros and Cons


Easy to install and repair – Asphalt roofs are much easier to install and maintain than metal. They are relatively easy to work with and small maintenance and repair work can be done without the need of an expert.

More economical – Average price for an asphalt shingle material is $5 to $9 per square foot and the average labor cost for the roof installation is $1.50 to $5.50 per square foot. This is very cheap compared to other materials.

Lots of variety – Asphalt shingles are one of the most visually appealing roof material available in the market. They are more likely to be consistent with other houses in the area, with a number of varieties available in the market.


Less durable and strength – Shingles are less durable and have lesser strength than metal. They are more prone to roof leak, mold and mildew
They are vulnerable to harsh weather, hail storm and UV rays.

Less lifespan – This type of roof last between 15 to 25 years on an average, which is lesser than metal roof. But this depends on how you take care of the roof. Some homeowners have even reported using shingle roof up to 35 years.

Less efficient – Shingles absorb heat and warms the home in the winter.
Due to this, they can make the home hotter in the summer.

Less ROI and sale value – Asphalt roofs generally don’t add much value to the house, due to their common nature and easy availability Architectural shingles will have a greater return than traditional ones.

Metal vs Asphalt Roof: Which Is Better?

In a nutshell, as you can see from the above comparison, metal roofing are better than asphalt shingles in terms of longevity, strength and durability, ROI and resale value, whereas shingles are better than metal in terms of cost-effectiveness, ease of installation and maintenance, and choices of design.

If you’re looking for signs for a new roof replacement, check out this article here. But if you’re looking for a professional roofer in Salt Lake City to help you make the best choice, you can contact us here.


1. Does a metal roof last longer than shingles?

Yes, metal roof lasts longer than shingles. An average lifespan of a metal roof is 40 to 70 years, whereas shingles have an average lifespan of 15 to 20 years.

2. Are metal roofs noisy?

Actually, they are not as noisy as they seem. They can effectively absorb the noise of the rain hail, windblown debris, and other extreme weather conditions.

3. Can metal roof be installed over asphalt shingles?

Yes, metal roof can be installed over asphalt shingles.

4. Is shingle roof really cheaper than metal roof?

Although metal roof is more expensive than asphalt shingle. In the long run, it is much cheaper, due to low maintenance cost.

5. Does metal roof leak more than shingle?

No, metal has a much higher resistance to damages and leaks.

Sharing is caring!